Charlotte Gray

Nagyon szép operatőri munka, jelmezek és általában a helyszín és a korszak történelmi ábrázolása. De a cselekménynek nincs motorja, és a film az utolsó negyedig túlságosan televíziós módra tompa és jellegtelen. Sőt, Cate Blanchett sem emelkedik ki a filmből, mintha a rendezőnő "a kevesebb néha több" utasítását követné. Ha nem lett volna a végén az a bizonyos dramatizálás, a film ugyanolyan hidegen hagyott volna, mint egy unalmas könyv olvasása. (2004.08.22)

Despite the excellent camera work, it is quite an average affair, mainly due to the script, which takes the somewhat cumbersome subject matter too seriously, thus undermining the tension. However, the characters ultimately find their way into the viewer's heart, and thanks to the captivating performance by Cate Blanchett and the excellent Michael Gambon, boredom is not a concern. (2007.01.30)

A romantic drama set in World War II that tells the story of a Scottish woman's tremendous determination to give up almost everything for the love of a man. Charlotte Gray is a film that tells the story of a very common theme today:war and its effects on those around it. It's an incredibly moving, telling story, and a very realistic one in terms of the anti-Semitism of the time. The whole film is accompanied by a beautiful musical score and the visual impact is provided by great cinematography. The actors were well very cast, a great Cate Blanchett and a great Billy Crudup with Michael Gambon. Truly, a film that doesn't lack quality and its only major issue on the overall image for me was the running time and a few other negligible little flaws. (2010.07.02)